44 Comments
User's avatar
johnycomelately's avatar

Red Sea, Black Sea and Panama Canal, seems like this more about business and reducing inflation than anything else.

AmericanCardigan's avatar

I still hold to the premise that bigger things are in play here.

Spheres of Influence based on geography.

US wrestling Israel as much as possible while Russia curtails Iran / Houthis.

Sidelining the UK/EU.

Sub-optimizing Ukraine needs in order to optimize larger goals. The give and take to make a bad situation look less bad eg. recognizing Crimea, loosening sanctions etc.

Joe's avatar

Alaistair Crooke seems to hint that either the US negotiation team is completely inexperienced and dumb as a box of rocks, or the Ukraine ceasefire was all a show and there was never any real intent on having a ceasefire it's just that Trump said he would so he did and apparently it was signed by the US.

No intent as it was not written in any customary sense

https://youtu.be/NXsykiIDK2g?t=196

Joe's avatar

Boris Johnson says it was all a show

"What a surprise - Putin rejects an unconditional ceasefire. He wants to keep bombing and killing innocent Ukrainians. He wants Ukraine disarmed. He wants Ukraine neutralised. He wants to make Ukraine a vassal state of Russia. He isn’t negotiating. He’s laughing at us."

https://x.com/BorisJohnson/status/1902117437018903037

AmericanCardigan's avatar

Who gives a rats arse what Boris Johnson says.

Joe's avatar

What I intended or meant was - my speculation

Trump - While knowing Putin's request(s) - and knowing US UK EU UA will never meet them ---- why not have a few phone calls - then write up a ceasefire proposal that does not address all of Putin's requests, write up a ceasefire that omits essential terms ( as Alaistair Crooke stated) write up a ceasefire you know will never be agreed to --- Sign it and send it to Putin

And then have your lackeys Johnson Rubio et al tell everyone you were the reasonable one, you offered a reasonable ceasefire, you met their requests, but Putin wants to kill innocent people so Putin denied your reasonable request. It's a game show.

Boris Johnson post merely indicates the speculation is correct

Stephen McIntyre's avatar

Bottom line is Russia will talk when Ukraine surrenders, no other options.

Trump will have to eat his Ego to get a deal.

SMH's avatar

As this situation continues to unfold, I am reminded of Ayn Rand’s words, “You can ignore reality but you can’t avoid it.”

SMH's avatar

Also OT, but CJ Roberts unsolicited public comments did not help change my low opinion of his performance. I wonder if he’s making note of the fact that the only source of this judicial overreach is coming from the “no Obama judges” side of the aisle!

Turns out there are “Obama judges and Bush judges and Trump judges”, huh, fancy that.

Steghorn21's avatar

I know our esteemed host has spoken up for Roberts's qualities as a defender of constitutional values, but I personally find it terrifying that the most crucial constitutional inflexion point since the US civil war may be decided by individuals like him and Coney Barrett.

Mark Wauck's avatar

The crisis of the judiciary has been building for many decades, and Roberts has only very limited control. He's trying to *steer* the judges back to within a reasonably constitutional role while maintaining the public prestige of the judiciary as a societal institution that is nonpartisan--the public perception. But his tools for doing that largely amount to trying to lead by restrained example.

Right now, I imagine he's trying to come up with some solution that will defend the prerogatives of the Executive while not seeming partisan. Not easy, because he can only do that within the parameters of the cases that come to him. He would prefer to see appellate courts get things right a few times first. There have been a few of those. He doesn't want to rush into this.

Cosmo T Kat's avatar

Yes, it has and the reasons are obvious. You can’t get the appellate court to act right when they are selected to do what they are doing, obstruction and defending corruption while enabling criminality. It’s called social justice. Irony.

Steghorn21's avatar

I hope you are right, Mark. With my head, I believe you. With my heart...

Mark Wauck's avatar

His statement today wasn't a *defense* of the Obama judges. It relied on a bit of a fiction, as if some of the judicial antics we're seeing fall within normal parameters on which reasonable legal scholars can agree to disagree. The reality, of course, is that many of these judges are documentably driven by partisan/ideological considerations that could wreak havoc going forward on our entire constitutional order, because they're obsessed with Orange Man Bad. In that context, Roberts' statement really was more of a warning to the judges to exercise restraint because Roberts has no control over what Congress could decide to do. They're playing with fire by being unreasonable.

Te Time's avatar

It’s always been the plan to attack Iran. It’s why we have built them up for the past forty years. Now it’s time to take them out.

Same with the Mexican cartels..

susan mullen's avatar

Mexican "cartels" serve a key function of poisoning the US, keeping it weak and off balance, and maximizing brutality and suffering which is exactly what US elites, the UK monarchy, and other globalists want to do. Queen Elizabeth even awarded Honorary Knighthoods to Mexican Presidents Vicente Fox (2002), Felipe Calderon (2009), Enrique Pena-Nieto (2015, and Ernesto Zedillo (1998). The Mexican "government" is fine with them. Mexican labor fleeing to US adds billions in remittances to Mexican economy.

Stephen McIntyre's avatar

You really think we have the ability to take Iran out? Not going to happen. Russia and China will support them and in turn with Russia's Hypersonic Missiles and Kinetic Energy bombs Israel will suffer and its army wiped out.

We don't even have the resources to put an Army in the field for any length of time, much less supply it and we have squandered much of out bombs and munitions on Ukraine and Israel and have not been able to recover.

Te Time's avatar

They are gonna try. Just like they planned. Iran the only one left. They took down Libya, Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, Somalia.

Westley Clark returned to Washington to see the same general and inquired whether the plan to strike Iraq was still under consideration. The general's response was stunning:

"'Oh, it's worse than that,' he said, holding up a memo on his desk. 'Here's the paper from the Office of the Secretary of Defense [then Donald Rumsfeld] outlining the strategy. We're going to take out seven countries in five years.' And he named them, starting with Iraq and Syria and ending with Iran."

While Clark doesn't name the other four countries, he has mentioned in televised interviews that the hit list included Lebanon, Libya, Somalia and Sudan. .

Joe's avatar

I read this reported in Turkey paper

perhaps interesting China Global Times had an article on a call being held, but not a followup

and India paper I read seemed to repeat US statements

"The two leaders also discussed the situation in the Middle East and the Red Sea region, pledging joint efforts to stabilize the situation in these crisis-stricken areas."

https://www.aa.com.tr/en/americas/putin-and-trump-discussed-bilateral-ties-ukraine-conflict-middle-east-kremlin/3513540

Note: China Global Times did report:

Hamas says head of its government in Gaza killed in Israeli airstrikes

By Xinhua

Published: Mar 18, 2025 05:35 PM

Hamas says head of its government in Gaza killed in Israeli airstrikes

https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202503/1330351.shtml

Mark Wauck's avatar

Tx. Running around a lot today. Is Trump creating a crisis to bring Russia in to help solve it? That would definitely qualify as multi-dimensional chess.

D F Barr's avatar

Attacking Iran is insane. The U.S. invasion and destruction of Iraq was a disaster. Attacking Iran would be exponentially worse. Next level insanity. Trump’s base would vaporize as well as the rest of the country. Want to ensure an opening for a domestic Marxist revolution and takeover of the U.S.? Invade Iran.

Joe's avatar

I recall this being discussed about the Oslo Accords and Clinton.

Here is an example:

"Accords did more to lay bare where the parties disagreed, than provide any real roadmap forward"

https://www.aaiusa.org/library/how-the-us-failed-oslo

Manul's avatar

Doesn’t read like a peace deal is imminent.

Mark Wauck's avatar

Not without more and substantial US concessions. Putin said nice public things to make Trump look good, but didn't budge on substance.

Steghorn21's avatar

Nothing has changed. Russia is still grinding forward. It would be interesting to do a daily comparison between the number of words exchanged in these "negotiations" and kilometres of Ukrainian territory captured by the Russians. I suspect the latter variable would be unaffected by the former.

Mark Wauck's avatar

Next meet in ME:

According to a statement from U.S. press secretary Karoline Leavitt, both Trump and Putin 'agreed' that the conflict in Ukraine 'needs to end with a lasting peace,' and that 'negotiations will begin immediately in the Middle East.'

Steghorn21's avatar

So is Trump going to impose his views on the Palestinians and Iranians like he did with Zelensky? If he believes he can do that, he is seriously underestimating the latter.