Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Wauck's avatar

Commenting re Rand Report:

Scott Ritter

@RealScottRitter

This is the kind of report the intellectual elite of a country whose collective mind has been corrupted by decades of Russophobia produces. It is so out of touch with reality that it approaches farcical proportions. It is, thus, quintessentially American.

Expand full comment
Cord The Seeker's avatar

"On its face that’s a total non-starter from the Russian standpoint, but is it an opening gambit? An invitation to Russia to make a counteroffer? Interestingly, Nuland claimed that she and Blinken are on the same page. And yet an article on Wednesday in the WaPo—presumably written by David Ignatius at Blinken’s direction—seems to hint at more flexibility."

I would be cautious about taking anything these people say at face value. For one thing, given that the President's brains are leaking out his ears, no one is really in charge. What Nuland says has nothing do, really, with what policy is. And if, hypothetically, the Russians decided to open negotiations for ending the war, that's a practical problem they'd have to deal with.

Remember that these people never intended to be in a long conventional war. They conducted a panicked evacuation of the Kiev embassy before the war began and offered to fly Zelensky to safety. (Leading to the famous "I need ammunition, not a ride." These days the ammo is running low and the ride may soon start looking better, but that is neither here nor there.) The point is, they thought Ukraine would fall quickly. (And so did Putin!) What this implies to me is that they made promises to Ukraine that they never had any intention of keeping. They wrote a blank check that they thought would never get cashed.

What this means is that they are dealing with the unintended consequences of mistakes made long ago, not executing some grand design. Truth be told, if Putin took them up on an offer of negotiations, they might not even know what to negotiate for. Nuland isn't making some well thought out offer of negotiations, she's just doing what they've been doing since day one and hoping something will turn up.

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts