Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mark Wauck's avatar

I forget who recommended the book, but I managed to get a reasonably priced used copy of When Titans Clashed: How The Red Army Stopped Hitler, and I'm finding it an engrossing read. Despite the title it's even handed. Many partisans of the Red Army Won The War school don't give credit where it's due. While D-Day didn't happen until half way through 1944, the North Africa campaign gobbled up scarce German reserves and airplanes--both transports and escorts. The same goes for our strategic bombing campaign. Even when it seemed of dubious benefit, the Germans were losing far more airplanes defending in the West than in the East, and the East was getting starved of replacements at the very time the Soviets were finally achieving parity. Among other things, Lend-Lease provided 2/3 of Red Army trucks. Without all this, once the Red Army definitively switched to the offensive they would have moved far slower than turned out to be the case, and would have incurred even heavier losses. None of that detracts from their sacrifices and achievements, nor that they shouldered the heaviest burden. Just perspective, which is what I was looking for in the book. It's an overview type account, rather than a who struck John detailed history.

Interestingly, in the conclusion the authors maintain that the understandable "never again" mentality engendered by the war ultimately led to the downfall of the Soviet economy and state, which was unable to support the strategy of buffer states and overseas attempts to detract from US global dominance. Presumably Putin has internalized these lessons, as his actions indicate.

Expand full comment
NFO's avatar

Another outstanding analysis and marshalling of relevant sources. Thank you!

Expand full comment
36 more comments...

No posts